
Written by William C. Duncan
September 6, 2023
Originally published in the National Review.
Americans are developing a distorted view of the proper role of the U.S. Supreme Court, thanks to an ongoing torrent of criticism from the press, politicians, and activist groups. To protect the constitutional order, it’s time for voters to reacquaint themselves with the true purpose of the nation’s highest court.
Utah senator Mike Lee (R.), speaking at the Sutherland Institute Congressional Series in August, pointed out that “structural protections in the Constitution” are often overlooked but provide a bulwark against dangerous concentrations of power. The Court, when it carefully adheres to its proper role, is one such protection.
Unfortunately, in attempting to stay true to its proper role, the Court has drawn intense criticism, particularly after the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision, in which the Court returned the authority to regulate abortion to the states. After a draft of the decision was leaked to the press, Gallup found that confidence in the Supreme Court had reached a “historic low.” Akin to the cliché of a bully pinning a victim down and making the child slap himself while taunting “stop hitting yourself,” the latest barrage against the Court should be interpreted as an effort to bully it out of…
More Insights
Read More
Will AI kill us in 10 years? | Chris Koopman & Ford Copple
Is AI really on track to destroy humanity, or are we confusing small risks with science fiction? On this episode of Defending Ideas, Nic Dunn sits down with Chris Koopman, CEO of Abundance Institute, and Ford Copple, tech policy analyst at Sutherland Institute, to discuss the growing debate over AI safety, regulation, data centers, and technological innovation.
Massachusetts case raises concerns about government cutting parents out of children’s decisions
When parents pose a threat to children’s safety, the state should act. But ideological disagreements are not a reason to cut parents out of a child’s life.
How Utah Fits All is helping students with special needs and other learning challenges
Education choice programs can change the course of a child’s life, expanding their knowledge and increasing their confidence, especially after a season of struggle with profound challenges. Utah should expand its education choice programs and offerings so more families have these experiences and more children can thrive.

