Written by Derek Monson
October 28, 2026
Originally published by Utah News Dispatch.
The Justice Department has struck out again after U.S. District Court Judge David Barlow dismissed a lawsuit against Utah Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson. While Judge Barlow correctly interpreted federal law, it is important for Americans to know that the ruling helps ensure our elections remain fair and secure.
The Trump administration, to its credit, wants to root out election fraud. But you do not do that by just demanding that states hand over sensitive voter data. The best way to fight election fraud is by following the system outlined in our Constitution.
Article I, Section 4 of the U.S. Constitution says that state legislatures shall determine the time, place and manner of elections to federal office. It also empowers Congress to alter some state election laws. In other words, states take the lead in running elections, Congress plays a secondary role as needed, and the president does what Congress tells him or her to do.
Nowhere does this give the executive branch the authority to make demands beyond those authorized by Congress. Nor does it allow for new election policy to be made via executive order or federal regulation, as recent executive orders and federal regulations around vote by mail (also paused by the courts) would do.
Widespread election fraud is prohibitively difficult to perpetrate in the United States because there are plenty of opportunities to catch it. That is the genius of our constitutionally designed system.
We have 50 state-led election systems administered by thousands of local election officials. These local election officials collect ballots and count votes, while state election officials provide oversight, add local vote tallies together and announce results.
Think about it: To perpetrate voter fraud on a scale that could change the outcome of a federal election, fraudsters would have to overcome the safeguards of dozens of election systems, while getting hundreds (perhaps thousands) of state and local election officials in on their schemes. Even in state races or smaller districts, dozens of state and local election officials would need to be in on the plot for election fraud to sway those elections. Persuading that many individuals from different geographies and independent jurisdictions to get on board with that deception is so difficult it is practically impossible.
Look at Utah if you want to see how difficult pulling off something like that would be.
More Insights
Read More
What does healthy masculinity look like? | Andrew Reiner
Today, a lot of boys are receiving mixed signals from our culture about masculinity and how men should behave. But parents and communities can help boys thrive by building stronger relationships and emotional resilience.
The Human-Centered Benefits of AI: Reality vs. Perception
From lifesaving medical research to practical tools that help local businesses operate more efficiently, AI is already producing meaningful, real-world benefits.
Americans fear AI will take jobs – but worry less about their own, new report and survey find
Sutherland Institute will co-host two events Oct. 27-28 focused on civil dialogue, family policy, and the demographic changes affecting Utah.

