Latest biased polling goes unquestioned by journalists

A new Washington Post-ABC News poll that is making lots of headlines, both nationally and locally, reported that opposition to “gay marriage” has fallen to a “new low,” with only 39 percent of the public opposed. It would seem noteworthy that less than four in 10 Americans oppose “gay marriage” – if not for the poll’s biased sample.

As an aside, a poll’s bias can be examined fairly simply, by taking a few moments to examine the background questions asked of poll respondents. This rather quick and painless quality-assurance process would seem to be a no-brainer for any journalist aspiring to achieve balanced, quality reporting. Yet even such basic questions about sample validity are often lost on many political reporters.

Looking at the poll’s results, we find that the partisan breakdown was 32 percent Democrat, 22 percent Republican, and 38 percent independent. This 10-percentage-point Democratic advantage in the polling sample stands in stark contrast with the most recent party ID polls, which show Democrats with only a 4-point advantage in one case, and even a 2-point disadvantage in another. Clearly, a poll that artificially depresses the number of Republicans in its sample is going to find “all-time lows” for opposition to “gay marriage,” not based on any reality but rather on a skewed polling sample.

Here’s hoping that those who claim to be political journalists will act like it when it comes to numbers fed to them by pollsters.

Related posts:

This entry was posted in Miscellaneous and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Diane-Robertson/1421813446 Diane Robertson

     It is interesting to me at how not true this poll really is. Just taking a look at what voters have done across 32 or so states is a better acknowledgement of what the people really think. http://unitedfamiliesinternational.wordpress.com/2012/05/09/the-truth-about-the-same-sex-marriage-vote/

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Diane-Robertson/1421813446 Diane Robertson

     It is interesting to me at how not true this poll really is. Just taking a look at what voters have done across 32 or so states is a better acknowledgement of what the people really think. http://unitedfamiliesinternational.wordpress.com/2012/05/09/the-truth-about-the-same-sex-marriage-vote/

  • jbt

    Below you will find the results of the same survey question based upon the random sampling of 1004 respondents with a statistical margin of error of 3.5% for the past 9 years. It should be noted that in this period of time public opinion on this issue has done a complete reversal.  My question to Derek is was the polling also biased in 2003 – 2010 when you agreed with the poll’s findings?

    The trend toward the willingness to grant the same rights and benefits to our gay brothers and sisters as the rest of us enjoy is unmistakable.  As far as the states that have voted against same sex marriage is concerned, the rights of a minority being decided by a vote by the majority rarely favors the minority.  The 14th amendment to the constitution guarantees equal protection to all citizens, not just those in the majority.  What would the state of civil rights be in our country today if equal rights for the black minority group had been put to a vote in each of the southern states. 

    Rights for gay couples is THE civil rights cause of the 21st century.  The Sutherland Institute unfortunately is not on the winning side of this issue—all of their kicking, screaming, and whining about “biased polls” notwithstanding.

    23. On another subject, do you think it should be legal or illegal
    for gay and lesbian couples to get married? Do you feel that way
    strongly or somewhat?

    ——— Legal ——— ——– Illegal ——– No
    NET Strongly Somewhat NET Somewhat Strongly opinion
    5/20/12 53 39 14 39 7 32 8
    3/10/12 52 36 17 43 7 36 5
    7/17/11 51 32 19 45 9 36 4
    3/13/11 53 36 17 44 9 35 3
    2/8/10 47 31 16 50 9 42 3
    4/24/09* 49 31 18 46 7 39 5
    6/4/06 36 24 13 58 7 51 5
    8/28/05 39 NA NA 58 NA NA 3
    8/29/04 32 18 14 62 10 52 5
    3/7/04 38 24 14 59 11 48 3
    2/22/04 39 25 13 55 6 49 6
    1/18/04 41 NA NA 55 NA NA 4
    9/7/03 37 NA NA 55 NA NA 7

  • jbt

    Below you will find the results of the same survey question based upon the random sampling of 1004 respondents with a statistical margin of error of 3.5% for the past 9 years. It should be noted that in this period of time public opinion on this issue has done a complete reversal.  My question to Derek is was the polling also biased in 2003 – 2010 when you agreed with the poll’s findings?

    The trend toward the willingness to grant the same rights and benefits to our gay brothers and sisters as the rest of us enjoy is unmistakable.  As far as the states that have voted against same sex marriage is concerned, the rights of a minority being decided by a vote by the majority rarely favors the minority.  The 14th amendment to the constitution guarantees equal protection to all citizens, not just those in the majority.  What would the state of civil rights be in our country today if equal rights for the black minority group had been put to a vote in each of the southern states. 

    Rights for gay couples is THE civil rights cause of the 21st century.  The Sutherland Institute unfortunately is not on the winning side of this issue—all of their kicking, screaming, and whining about “biased polls” notwithstanding.

    23. On another subject, do you think it should be legal or illegal
    for gay and lesbian couples to get married? Do you feel that way
    strongly or somewhat?

    ——— Legal ——— ——– Illegal ——– No
    NET Strongly Somewhat NET Somewhat Strongly opinion
    5/20/12 53 39 14 39 7 32 8
    3/10/12 52 36 17 43 7 36 5
    7/17/11 51 32 19 45 9 36 4
    3/13/11 53 36 17 44 9 35 3
    2/8/10 47 31 16 50 9 42 3
    4/24/09* 49 31 18 46 7 39 5
    6/4/06 36 24 13 58 7 51 5
    8/28/05 39 NA NA 58 NA NA 3
    8/29/04 32 18 14 62 10 52 5
    3/7/04 38 24 14 59 11 48 3
    2/22/04 39 25 13 55 6 49 6
    1/18/04 41 NA NA 55 NA NA 4
    9/7/03 37 NA NA 55 NA NA 7

  • jbt

    The spacing of the poll did not transfer well in my post.  To see the numbers more clearly, go to this link and scroll down to question #23.

     http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/polls/postabcpoll_20120520.html

  • jbt

    The spacing of the poll did not transfer well in my post.  To see the numbers more clearly, go to this link and scroll down to question #23.

     http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/polls/postabcpoll_20120520.html