‘Education savings accounts’: a game-changing idea


For you parents out there with students in high school, how would you like it if you were given a chunk of money to pay for the best high school education possible for your child, with the flexibility to take the best math class from one public school and the best English class in another public school? Further, how would you like it if, after your child’s customized education were paid for, you were allowed to keep any leftover money to pay for college?

This personalized, parent-centered approach to public education may be coming soon to a public school near you.

A Utah County legislator, Rep. John Dougall (R-Highland), recently proposed that the state institute a system of “education savings accounts” (ESA) that would give parents a pool of money (about $6,000) to use to pay for their child’s education. The funds would go proportionally to public schools based on how many classes a student was enrolled in at that school. Anything left over at the end of the year would stay in a student’s ESA, and at the end of high school, money in the ESA could be used to pay for college.

This policy would be good for Utah families on several levels. First, it would recognize parents’ fundamental right to “exercise primary control over the … education of their children.” Second, it would empower Utah parents with tools they need to direct their child’s education – namely, control of public education funding and the ability to choose what their child’s education looks like. Third, especially when coupled with the state’s new public school data website for parents, it would encourage innovation and improvement in public schools by giving parents the ability to reward schools that perform at a high level (in one or multiple academic categories) by sending their child’s ESA funds to that school.

Certainly, many details need to be worked out with this policy, which exists primarily at a conceptual level at this point. But these are the kinds of innovative, game-changing education policy ideas that Utah policymakers should be looking at and pursuing. Otherwise, there’s little chance that Utah’s public schools will become what we all want them to be.

This entry was posted in Education, Parental Rights and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • Shumaces

    This is a great idea!  We’ve always thought that the parents should be able to choose and be in control of their children’s education.  And rather than just dump it into the school mandated by the state that the child attend, the education would really improve, if they had to live up to a standard of excellence in order to have the child attend their particular school.

    But then the laws have to back out and let the teachers perform to their ability rather create curriculum based on things like no child left behind.  Let those teachers actually teach what they know that they can, if left alone to do so.  Tenure would not be the important, deciding factor as to who could teach and who could not.  It would become a matter of teaching excellence.

    I’m also wondering how that would affect home schoolers and private schools?  Do parents get to use the $6,000 to educate their children and give them opportunities outside the public education system?  Just curious.

    • Derek H. Monson

      Your question about home school and private school students is a good one.  It’s a question that we have as well, but that we haven’t yet clarified with Rep. Dougall. 

      As long as they’re paying the same taxes in support of public education as everyone else, I would hope that there would be some way to include them.  Otherwise, I think that home school and private school families should pay a lower state income tax rate.  They should pay something in support of public education, but it should take into account their decision to be educationally self-reliant.

  • Pingback: Education savings accounts offer a way to reward high achievers | Sutherland Daily()

  • Pingback: Capitol Daily Memo: education savings accounts bill unveiled | Sutherland Daily()